Date Published

Excel vs. Camasys: an honest comparison for car rental companies

Excel is great for a budget or a shopping list. But once it's running 30 cars, three branches and a summer or tough winter season, it becomes the most expensive "free" program in your company. A spreadsheet mistake usually shows up at the counter, while the customer is standing there.

Six situations compared

  • Double booking: in Excel you find out when two customers stand at the counter. In Camasys you see it right away on the planner timeline.
  • Online booking: in Excel it means an email, retyping and a phone call. In Camasys it goes from the website straight into the system.
  • Matching a car: in Excel it's down to the manager's memory, in Camasys it happens automatically by class, mileage and branch.
  • Invoice: in Excel you write it by hand after the shift. In Camasys it goes out automatically after payment.
  • Damage: in Excel it often ends with "That was already there". In Camasys you have time-stamped photos from the handover.
  • Who changed what: in Excel nobody knows. In Camasys the audit logs and role-based access show it.

Excel calculates correctly. The trouble is that it can't tell what's happening at the branch right now.

Where Excel quietly loses money

You won't see these losses in a spreadsheet:

  • a car sits in the lot because nobody spotted the free slot in the bookings,
  • a fee or an extra never makes it onto the invoice,
  • someone on the team spends the evening copying contracts from paper,
  • a customer loses trust when you discover a double booking at the counter.

One missed extra a week looks small, but over a year it adds up.

When Excel is still enough

With five cars, one branch and bookings by phone only, a spreadsheet can cope.

Things change when:

  • you add a second branch or seasonal staff,
  • you want to take online bookings from your own website,
  • you need to know which car makes money and which one just sits there,
  • you want customers to sign contracts digitally.

If even one of these applies to you, the spreadsheet is probably slowing you down.

Client results

  • PaylessCar has 50 % less manual work.
  • RentCarNow increased vehicle utilisation by 24 %.
  • AUTO IN no longer retypes data by hand.

Three questions before you decide

  • How many cars and branches will you have a year from now?
  • Who retypes data today, and for how many hours a week?
  • Which mistakes happened more than once in the last month?

Moving off Excel in three steps

  1. Export your cars, customers and upcoming bookings from Excel.
  2. Import them into Camasys via CSV, with no retyping row by row.
  3. Start with one branch as a pilot, and add the others once the team is comfortable.

And what about my spreadsheets?

You keep them. You import the data from CSV or Excel, and your accountant keeps getting scheduled exports in the format they're used to. Excel can stay for budgets, while bookings and cars live in the system.

See the comparison live. Book a demo at camasys.com.

Share

Explore

Get in touch to see how we can help

Book a demo